Menards Fertilizer Vs Scotts (Which is the Superior Choice)

Are you struggling with figuring out the best fertilizer for your lawn plants? Well, two of the best fertilizers are Menards and Scotts. So, which one should you pick?

Actually, picking between Menards and Scotts fertilizer can be difficult. But don’t panic! We will help you resolve the issue.

So, which one is better between Menards fertilizer vs Scotts?

Menards and Scotts fertilizers operate similarly. Menards organic fertilizer is beneficial to the soil. A former pollutant, Scotts is an inorganic fertilizer. Menards use natural ingredients including compost, dung, and bone meal. Using inorganic or chemical fertilizers feeds your lawn.

This might not be sufficient information to make you understand which one to choose. So, we have this whole article for you to help you in making a decision.

So let’s get into the specifics of the comparison.

Quick Overview of Menards Vs Scotts

Menards natural fertilizer can be used on everything from lawns, trees, flower beds to rose bushes.

Using Menards fertilizer ensures a steady supply of nutrients for 8 to 10 weeks. Plus, there is no risk of of overgrowth or burns.

Dark green grass is the result of using Scotts fertilizer. However, overuse of Scotts might destroy the lawn.

Both fertilizers are of exceptionally high quality. In their own universes, they each serve a function.

But when you are going to make a proper fertilizer you need to have different items. These include a hoss seeder, shovel, etc. Make sure to keep them ready.

Here I am suggesting the 2 best quality shovels.

Choose any of them and hope you’ll no longer face any problem related to shovels.

Menards Fertilizer Vs Scotts: Basic Differences

You have already understood these two fertilizers are of excellent grade. Now, let’s look at the fundamental differences between Menards fertilizer and Scotts fertilizer.

Menards FertilizerScotts Fertilizer
Menards fertilizer that is high in nutrientsIt's a type of synthetic fertilizer
It has a low impact on the environmentIt has the potential to degrade soil
When it is utilized, the nutrients in the soil are retained for a longer period of timeWhen it's used, the nutrients don't last very long in the soil
Natural ingredients including compost, manure, and bone meal are used to make Menards fertilizersInorganic compounds or chemicals are used in synthetic fertilizers to supply nutrients to your lawn
Summer is considered the best season to use this fertilizerThe cold-weather is the optimal time to apply this fertilizer

Are you still struggling to understand what you want? It’s all right, we’ve got you covered. Take a seat and take in a head-to-head comparison.

Menards Fertilizer Vs Scotts: Head to Head Battle

menards fertilizer vs scotts

We understand that merely identifying the fundamental differences will not suffice. Therefore, sit back and enjoy the battle between Menards Fertilizer and Scotts Fertilizer.


The grass takes a long time to absorb the Menard fertilizer. As a result, grass grows slower than usual.

On the other hand, Scotts fertilizer generates significantly more lush-looking dark green grass. We loved Scott’s smaller particle size. Your lawn grass will be able to absorb them quickly.

Special Features

Menards fertilizer has unique characteristics that are managed in their release. Scott’s distinguishing feature is a proprietary water-smart PLUS coating. It absorbs water two times greater than an uncoated seed. 

Moreover, this fertilizer helps to kickstart plant growth. Along with that, they protect seedlings from disease. It may thrive with as little as 3 hours of sunshine every day.

Coverage Area

Organic fertilizer should be applied at a rate of 10 pounds per 1,000 square feet of surface area.

When you are using soluble inorganic nitrogen fertilizer, we have an advice for you. Utilize only one pound of nitrogen per 1,000 square feet of soil for a single application of the fertilizer.

Fertilizer from Menards 15,000 sq. ft. is covered by a 51-pound bag.

Scott’s 17-pound bag will cover 5,000 square feet.

If you are looking for the best nitrogen fertilizer, have a look at the product table.

These products will serve you the best. So you can use any of them without hesitation.

There isn’t a clear winner in this contest. If we had to choose one, it would almost certainly be a Menards because it is an environmentally friendly fertilizer. 

However, Scotts is the business to call if you need fast-acting remedies for your lawns.

Which One is Appropriate for You?

Before selecting a solution for your grass, you should consider the needs of your yard and rank them accordingly.

If you want a fertilizer for versatile usage then undoubtedly Menards should be your first choice. Plus, if you want to ensure a long-term health of soil choose Menards. 

On the other hand, If you want to promote a more vibrant, green lawn then Scotts fertilizer would be a better choice. But keep in mind, It is a synthetic fertilizer that may injure the soil.

If you want to monitor the overall condition of soil, get any of the suggested pH meters.

Frequently Asked Questions

Question: What is the purpose of organic fertilizer?

Answer: Organic fertilizers are by-products of natural breakdown that plants readily absorb. Organic fertilizers provide continuous nutrients to garden plants. It strengthens and self-sustains your plants.

Question:  What effect do inorganic fertilizers have on the soil?

Answer: Inorganic fertilizer raises soil pH. Water-stable aggregates help withstand soil erosion. Inorganic fertilizer decreased the size of these aggregates. Over inorganic and control treatments, manure increased soil electrical conductivity.

Question: How does inorganic fertilizer affect the environment? 

Answer:  Extra nutrients from fertilizer washed into rivers and generate algae blooms. Besides, at the time the algae die, they sink to the bottom and dissolve, depleting the water of oxygen.

Bottom Line

Now, we have finally completed our review guideline about menards fertilizer vs scotts. We are hopeful that you will be able to select the most appropriate fertilizer for your grass.

You can contact a specialist if you have any additional questions or need assistance.

Have a great day!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *